Residential Combustion Analyzers

To measure combustion efficiency you need a tool that can measure either the oxygen or CO2 content of the combustion gasses. For many years, an hour glass shaped bubbler containing a fluid that absorbs CO2 or O2 was used. They are difficult to find these days. They have been replaced by electronic instruments. These use an electro-chemical reaction in an oxygen sensor to measure the O2 content in the flue gases. They use thermistors to read the flue gas temperature and ambient temperature, so they have all the information that need to calculate and display combustion efficiency. They use this information to display CO2 %, O2 %, combustion efficiency, % excess air, flue gas temperature, and net stack temperature. Most offer other measurements as well. Some of the more common additional features include:

• CO ppm – to read the CO in the flue gas

• CO ppm air free – to calculate the CO ppm after removing the excess air

• Draft pressure – to insure you actually have a draft

• Differential draft pressure – to insure the draft pressure is lower than the room pressure

• NOX – to comply with NOX regulations in areas that restrict furnace NOX emissions

• Printer – to print out reports from results

• Computer Connectivity – to import data from analyzer to programs on your computer

Prices vary a good bit. From just over $500 for no-frills analyzers intended for residential work, to several thousand for commercial instruments. Certificates of NIST traceability often cost more.  Most combustion analyzers use electro-chemical sensors. These have a limited life because the chemicals in them are used up as they work. Typical replacement time is every one to two years. Some are user replaceable, and others require sending in the tool for the sensors to be replaced. This will typically cost $200 - $300. The table below compares several of the lower priced models which are aimed at the residential market.

	Bacharach Intech	Testo 310	UEI C75	E Instruments BTU 900
O2	yes	yes	yes	yes
CO2	yes	yes	yes	yes
Efficiency	yes	yes	yes	yes
Excess Air	yes	yes	yes	yes
CO	yes	yes	yes	yes
Air Free CO	yes	yes	no	yes
Draft pressure	no	yes	no	yes
Differential Pressure	no	no	no	yes
NOX	no	no	no	Can upgrade
Printer	Available Extra Cost	Available Extra Cost	Available Extra Cost	Available Extra Cost
Computer Connectivity	no	no	No	USB & Bluetooth
Field replaceable sensor	yes	no	no	yes
Fuels	6	5	5	10
Warranty	2 years	2 years	3 years	2 year
Approximate Street Price	$520	$600	$500	$1000

Combustion Efficiency

Fall tune up season is here. A seasonal check on a gas or oil furnace should include a check of the combustion process. To do a good job you really need to measure the combustion efficiency. To measure combustion efficiency you need to take two temperature readings and one flue gas reading.  The temperatures are the flue gas temperature and the ambient temperature around the unit. You subtract the ambient temperature from the flue gas temperature to get what is called the net stack temperature. The flue gas reading can be either CO2 or O2.Generally oxygen is preferred. For a gas furnace, perfect stoichiometric combustion produces 12% CO2 in the flue gas. The CO2 percentage drops off if the process is either too rich (too much fuel) or too lean (too much air). At the perfect stoichiometric point the O2 will still be 0% because all of it is being used in the combustion process. As excess air is introduced into the process, the O2 begins to rise due to the oxygen content in the air that was not used in the combustion process. Excess air is introduced to insure complete combustion. Note that complete combustion is not the same as perfect combustion. In perfect (stoichiometric) combustion, ALL the fuel and ALL the oxygen are used up, producing ONLY carbon dioxide and water. In complete combustion, all the fuel is used up, but not necessarily all the oxygen. Lack of combustion air produces incomplete combustion. Incomplete combustion leaves some unburned carbon and carbon monoxide. Excess air is introduced on purpose to prevent the production of soot and CO in the flue gas. The figure below shows the relationship of CO2, CO, O2 , and excess air. Next week we will discuss some of the ore practical aspects of measuring the combustion process.